Cause or Effect?

Screenshot

In a previous essay, I presented a model relating energy use with economic growth, with an implicit understanding that the economy resulted from the use of that energy. It was a puzzle to me why economic growth would be higher than energy growth, but the relationship existed.

As I think about it further, the cause of economic growth is not the energy applied; it is an expectation that has been built into our societal structure. To meet that expectation, we harvest whatever energy is needed to generate it. If there was not an expectation for economic growth, there would be no need to increase our energy supply.

And the growth we expect each year is not just from expanding capitalism’s wealth, it is also because more is needed to feed and maintain a growing population. So there are two components: feeding the population, and improving its standard of living. If the population were stable, we would be left with trying to improve everyone’s lot in life. If we were satisfied with our lives, and the population was flat, would we still seek economic growth?

It may be a moot question because the premise of humans ever being satisfied seems unlikely.

We can tease out the two components of growth by looking at per capita GDP; in other words, how much of the GDP is just a reflection of increased population. In a world where everyone is satisfied and stays at the same standard of living, per capita GDP should be constant. Instead we see that it is also growing, albeit at a lower level than the total. That growth represents how much better off, and how much more stuff we all have (collectively that is; it is not uniformly distributed).

So the increasing population, and the increasingly modern lifestyle of that population, create an increased demand for energy. This provides the motivation to extract it from more and more sources, one of which, fossil fuels, is a finite resource whose limits we are starting to learn.

Projections show that the population will stabilize eventually, regardless of energy limits. It will happen coincidentally with the peak of fossil fuel extraction, and so we will be left with a population whose needs must be met with a diminishing supply of energy. Enhancements to lifestyle can be suspended, but the need to feed everyone is still there. With the shortfall of energy, the deficit will be made up by decreases in lifestyle.

It’s not a rosy outcome, but if we have a prediction for our future, we can prepare for it. My purpose here is to attempt to change our expectations for unlimited growth by showing what happens if we insist on maintaining it. The sooner we abandon this paradigm, the less overshoot and suffering we will encounter as we pass the halfway mark of fossil fuel resources.

A Slave to Growth

With a model for the supply and cost of fossil fuels, we can predict what happens as they become depleted. Recall that the model for extraction followed a logistic curve, which is commonly used to represent population growth with natural levels of reproduction, predation, food supply and other resources. There is a natural feedback: as a population exceeds its food supply, its growth slows to zero and then reverses, resulting in a population crash, which allows the food resource to renew, and the cycle can start over. The logistic curve serves well for modeling such dynamics.

This is what happens in the natural world. In our human world, we have found ways to avoid this pattern, but it relies on extracting energy to make more food to support a population that has exceeded its food supply. The “green revolution”, which is a term used to describe our modern energy-intensive farming methods, has allowed us to reach a population of 8 billion.

Extracting the concentrated stored energy of fossil fuels has also enabled an expanding economy to support an amazing lifestyle. We are all beneficiaries of this outcome. And that economy has been expanding for a long time, as long as we have been alive, and during the lives of our parents and grandparents. We can’t remember when it wasn’t expanding.

The expanding economy has become ingrained in the economy itself. We no longer look for stable profits in a business; we look for ever-increasing returns. It is expected that the economy will grow every year, as measured by indices such as the “gross domestic product,” GDP: the total value of all goods and services provided in a year.

If the economy does not grow, we declare that it is in recession, and something must be done to correct it. Corporate and political leadership take measures to do so. The economy is a complex thing, but there are a few controls at their disposal to try and right the ship. These are things that most of us (including me) do not fully understand, but include interest rates, money supply, taxes, subsidies, investments, fiscal policies, trade policies, and energy policies.

These are all things that impact next year’s GDP. Underneath the complexity of the economy, and widely unrecognized, is our dependence on fossil fuels to maintain it. In keeping with my “keep it simple” model of our modern world, I postulate that the GDP is entirely dependent on the energy we obtain from fossil fuels. This dependency is obscured by the volatility that results from our policies to maintain growth.

I make the assertion that our modern economy is proportional to the energy we extract. In a previous post, I showed how the world GDP grows at about 3X the growth of fossil fuel consumption. I will continue that relation in what follows. Most economists would claim that I have reversed cause and effect. They would explain that the economy grows, which requires more energy, a simple commodity which is supplied according to demand, with no impact from its (unacknowledged ) finite supply.

These are the assumptions of macroeconomics. As a physicist, I know this can’t be right. So what might be right?

I have created two scenarios where we become slaves to growth. In the first, we expect a fixed annual increase in the GDP, and so we extract enough energy to accomplish it. Because the cost of energy is so little and grows slowly, we don’t notice. In fact, even with increasing energy extraction costs, we mine as much as we need every year to meet the target GDP growth. Eventually the costs become so high that we spend more energy than we get back, but by then, the supply has become depleted. No amount will keep the growth going, and the economy collapses.

And it collapses dramatically. The natural logistic curve would have an inflection point, but this simulated extraction curve continues to steepen until it runs out of resource to extract. This is because the normal feedback to slow down (the cost of extraction) has been overridden by the demand for economic growth, no matter how much fossil fuel is needed each year to meet it.

In this simulation where a GDP growth of 4% was driving the extraction of energy, the resource is depleted by 2031. Note that the world GDP data (normalized to the year 2000) is running a little above the simulated GDP.

With a constant growth of GDP, energy is extracted at ever-increasing annual rates, never displaying a peak, as would be found in a more natural logistic curve, shown here for comparison.

The expected “peak oil” marker never occurs, because we force the extraction to increase every year, never mind its cost. This is, I think, part of the reason we have not seen the signature of peak oil at the various times it has been predicted. We have reached the halfway mark of the resource supply, and despite its increasing difficulty, we have not reduced the amount we extract, we have just accepted the cost increase. We accept the cost increase because it remains a small amount contributing to what we consider normal inflation.

It is not until it becomes a large component of our inflation experience that it starts to matter. By then it is too late. The costs of extraction soon skyrocket and the EROI energy return on investment drops to 1 barrel of oil equivalent needed to extract 1 barrel of oil.

This is unrealistic of course. Who would keep demanding a GDP increase when the cost of energy becomes uneconomic? Well, this is a deeply ingrained expectation and there may be many things that are tried first. “Drill, baby, drill” will be a hard attitude to change.

As unrealistic as this scenario is, it fulfills my goal of finding the “limit of unlimited growth.” When the policy requires a constant annual increase in GDP, we extract our fossil fuel resources at ever-increasing amounts until they are depleted. At which time the GDP collapses for lack of energy to sustain it. We can reduce the expected annual growth rate in the model, but the same outcome happens — just a little bit later.

In reality, we don’t demand constant GDP growth. It fluctuates, sometimes even going negative, and the trend shows it gradually diminishing. My second scenario introduces the concept of inflation. When GDP numbers are reported, it is provided as a pair of numbers. The first is “nominal GDP,” the dollar value of all goods and services. But when there is inflation, the dollar changes value and has less purchasing power. So when inflation is factored in, the GDP is scaled down to the “real GDP,” the effective output of the country/world as if there was no inflation.

In this second scenario, instead of demanding a constant annual real GDP increase, we only demand that the nominal GDP increase by our target amount. The real GDP will be a bit less, but on paper, without inflation adjustments, we will have achieved our target. I find this mild deception completely believable since our financial institutions report their returns without factoring in inflation.

For the inflation factor, I use the increasing costs of extracting energy. The consumer price index inflation that we are more familiar with is the result of a much larger dynamic between countries, corporations and society. The energy cost inflation is currently a tiny amount of it, but as the energy resource is depleted, it will become significant. I make no attempt to include any other sources of inflation; it is strictly the increasing cost of energy, as modeled by the cost curve described in the previous post.

A simulation driven by a 5% constant growth in nominal GDP. Inflation is the cost of energy extraction, which remains relatively low until nearing resource depletion.
GDP Growth rates, inflation, and extraction rates for the scenario where energy is extracted to maintain a constant nominal GDP increase of 5%. The logistic extraction curve is shown for comparison.

This time, the extraction proceeds as before, but it slows down as inflation rises. The economy doesn’t crash until 2045, a full 15 years after the previous scenario. Annual extraction departs from the logistic curve as before, but appears to be approaching a peak just as the resource reaches depletion, rather than peaking at the resource 50% level as in the logistic model.

When the actual extraction data is superposed on this simulation (normalized at year 2000), it is eerily close. This is the situation I described earlier where the increased extraction, above the logistic curve, is obscuring the signal of reaching an extraction peak, which would tell us that we are at the halfway mark in using our total stored energy supply.

In both of these (synthetic) simulations, I adjusted the target growth rate so that the simulated GDP roughly matched the actual measured GDP. For the first scenario, this was 4%. As noted, it was held constant, when in reality, the data shows the GDP growth rate diminishing from around 10% to 4%.

In the second scenario, the nominal GDP target was 5%, selected so that, again, the simulated GDP under these conditions matched the measured GDP.

Both of these scenarios demonstrate the conflict between the demands for economic growth, which depends on the continued supply of fossil fuels, and the finite supply of those fuels. The models used for this demonstration were simple but not implausible. And the conditions for economic growth were artificial, but illustrate what would happen if perfect conformance to growth goals were to happen.

In reality, policy makers believe energy extraction follows the economy rather than the other way around, so they will not directly order the extraction of ever more oil and gas, but will pave the way for it, eventually providing subsidies and other incentives to keep the energy flowing.

The world and the economy are vastly more complex than this simple model. And the future will certainly not track exactly the extrapolations made here. But I expect the large pattern illustrated to play out, with deviations in the details. As we approach depletion, it will become more apparent that something is not right. By then, I fear it will be too late.

I’m not sure how it will eventually dawn on us that the problem is growth itself, not the resources to fuel it. Until we get the cause and effect right, we will continue to head toward an energy and economic cliff.

Previous: The Supply and Cost of Fossil Fuels

This entry was posted in Limits to Growth. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *