[Original draft 2024-11-15. After publishing my original series of posts analyzing the twins paradox, I realized I had more to say. This and the next post were written a few months later, but not published. A recent memory about an old textbook brought me back to this theme.]
I published a series of posts about the twins paradox and got bemused responses from those who looked at it. It is a popular puzzle among physics nerds, but most of us are not bothered by such impossible scenarios.
I did however, get a reply from someone who made an effort to resolve it with me, yet came up short. We both agreed that the paradox was broken by the situations not being symmetric (one twin experienced acceleration; the other did not). There was no paradox, yet there was still a puzzling discrepancy. Why would one twin’s path through spacetime result in a different time experience? What was the cause of it?
It didn’t seem to matter whether the acceleration (to change directions and return home) happened gradually or instantly; there was always a net proper-time difference. So the details of the acceleration didn’t seem to matter. Acceleration would not explain the time discrepancy.
I considered some other scenarios. Here’s one I found amusing. Recall that the twins Amelia and Ben take different life paths: Amelia stays home while Ben travels to an exoplanet three light-years away, and then returns to find that Amelia has aged during his absence. But what if Ben stays on the exoplanet, and Amelia travels to join him there. Guess what? When they reunite, they are the same age!
Continue reading















